Subject: RESULT: talk.media.*, misc.industry.media.journalism all fail From: warren@syra.net (Warren Lavallee) Date: Tue, 11 Jul 1995 11:42:43 -0600
How the Web Was Won
Subject: RESULT: talk.media.*, misc.industry.media.journalism all fail From: warren@syra.net (Warren Lavallee) Date: Tue, 11 Jul 1995 11:42:43 -0600
Organization: Usenet Volunteer Votetakers
Message-ID: 

                                RESULT
         unmoderated group talk.media.journalism fails 93:21
            unmoderated group talk.media.misc fails 87:32
        unmoderated group talk.media.net-coverage fails 93:24
     unmoderated group misc.industry.media.journalism fails 96:22

 Yes   No : 2/3? >100? : Pass? : Group
---- ---- : ---- ----- : ----- : -------------------------------------------
  93   21 :  Yes    No :    No : talk.media.journalism
  87   32 :  Yes    No :    No : talk.media.misc
  93   24 :  Yes    No :    No : talk.media.net-coverage
  96   22 :  Yes    No :    No : misc.industry.media.journalism
   3 invalid votes

Newsgroups line:
talk.media.journalism	Journalism and the news media.
talk.media.misc	The mass media.
talk.media.net-coverage	Feedback to media coverage of the Internet.
misc.industry.media.journalism	The profession of journalism (Moderated).

This vote was being conducted by a neutral third party. For voting
questions only contact Warren Lavallee . For questions
about the proposed group contact Aaron Priven .

CHARTER

* misc.industry.media.journalism

misc.industry.media.journalism is proposed as a moderated discussion
group for those interested in the profession and practice of journalism.
It will be moderated to ensure that posts are relevant and of interest
to those who are working journalists.

Most subjects relevant to the journalistic profession and the
news industry would be relevant. This would include "shop
talk" by journalists, information on student journalism, and
help on how to enter the field.

However, several kinds of messages are particularly irrelevant and
are out of place:

o Media criticism
o "Important stories not being covered by the media"
o Press releases
o Discussion of current events that happen to be covered by the media
o Personal attacks and flames
o Political discussions not directly related to the profession of
  journalism

Rejected articles will be made available on the Internet from
ftp.chrysopylae.com for at least one month after they are rejected.

The moderator will be Aaron Priven (aaron@chrysopylae.com and
aaronrp@best.com).

Submission address: journalism@chrysopylae.com
Contact address: journalism-request@chrysopylae.com

* talk.media.journalism

talk.media.journalism will be created as an unmoderated discussion group
for criticism of journalism and general discussion of journalism,
media, and society.

* talk.media.net-coverage

talk.media.net-coverage will be a Usenet newsgroup for discussion
of the various stories on the Internet that appear in professional
mass media: newspapers, magazines, radio broadcasts, TV reports,
and Internet forums such as World Wide Web pages for the professional
media.  Members of this newsgroup are encouraged to post commentaries
and reviews on these stories, so as to give additional information
to people who have read these reports on the Net and want to learn
more.  Members of the mass media will be able to receive feedback
on their reports through this newsgroup, and they will likewise
have the opportunity to alert the members of the Internet to be
prepared for upcoming reports on the Internet.

This newsgroup is not to be a forum for posting of press releases or
job applications.

This newsgroup will serve as a replacement for the current Usenet
newsgroup alt.internet.media-coverage.  Thanks to news@nova.avid.com,
the original creator of alt.internet.media-coverage.

* talk.media.misc

talk.media.misc will be a general forum for discussion of the media,
generally, although not necessarily, from a social or political
perspective.  Discussion of entertainment _as_ entertainment should
continue to be held in the appropriate group for the purpose (likely
under the rec.arts heirarchy).

[This collection of addresses is (C)1995 by Consultix Computer Services.
Permission is strictly NOT given to use this list or any part thereof to
make a mailing list, or for mass-mailings.  Any other use is fine.]
talk.media Final Vote Ack


                                        misc.industry.media.journalism ------+
                                               talk.media.net-coverage -----+|
                                                       talk.media.misc ----+||
                                                 talk.media.journalism ---+|||
                                                                          ||||
aaron@chrysopylae.com                                        Aaron Priven YY-Y
aa_adro@vega.concordia.ca                                  Andres Adrover YYYN
adair@bigpine.csee.usf.edu                                 Jonathan Adair NYNY
afabbro@umich.edu                                           Andrew Fabbro ---N
agunn@pipeline.com                                            Angela Gunn YYYY
ahm@sashimi.wwa.com                                   Andrew H. Marrinson N-NN
AJCMARYN@aol.com                                            Maryn McKenna YYYY
ananda@cs.utexas.edu                                        Ananda M. Kar YYYY
andyl@harlequin.com                                            Andy Latto YNYY
andyo@ora.com                                                 Andrew Oram YNYY
ao474@freenet.carleton.ca                                      Janet Kegg YYYY
ault@cs.albany.edu                                               Jim Ault YYYY
bdasun@ibl.bm                                                Ahmed ElAmin ---Y
bfant@charm.net                                                Bill Fant  YYYY
bjv@herbison.com                                            B.J. Herbison -Y--
BobCunning@aol.com                                         Bob Cunningham YYYY
C.R.Gadsden@politics.hull.ac.uk                           Richard Gadsden YYY-
callbritton@major.cei.net                                Chris Allbritton YYYY
cbranson@gate.net                                           Craig Branson YYYY
cbstone@phoenix.Princeton.EDU                        Christopher B. Stone NNNY
chriss@avbry.demon.co.uk                                      Chris Stent YYYY
crookes@ucon.gun.de                                        Philip Crookes YYYY
crouchkp@flidh101.delcoelect.com                                K. Crouch ----
csaamw@urc.tue.nl                                          Michiel Wijers NNNN
dan.r@ix.netcom.com                                        Dan Rothschild YYYY
dhartung@mcs.com                                              Dan Hartung NYYY
dmosher@nyx10.cs.du.edu                                      David Mosher NNYY
draziw@netcom.com                                                    Ryan YYYY
DS6537%CMSUVMB.BITNET@UBVM.CC.BUFFALO.EDU                    Don Kingston YYYY
dwillis@grove.ufl.EDU                                        Derek Willis YYYY
efoley@usa1.com                                                  Ed Foley ---Y
egarbos@sanders.com                                           Eric Garbos NNYN
ejhupper@rs6000.cmp.ilstu.edu                               Eric Huppertz YYYY
embransc@hamlet.uncg.edu                                 Edward Branscomb YYNN
fche@elastic.org                                         Frank Ch. Eigler YYYY
finn@netcom.com                                               Robert Finn YYYY
FWAADV@aol.com                                                Greg Brooks YYYY
geenius@Logical.NET                                          Keith Ammann YYYN
gerdw@cougar.vut.edu.au                                      David Gerard YYYY
gordon@yuki                                                  Gordon Engel NNNN
gronkin@nerdvana.com                                        George Ronkin YYYY
horowitz@omnifest.uwm.edu                                   Rick Horowitz YYYY
hrow@casbah.acns.nwu.edu                                  Ewing Heath Row YYYY
illumine@gate.net                                           Aaron Zollman -YY-
jamesh@achilles.net                                       James Hrynyshyn YYYY
jbell@solar.rtd.utk.edu                                  Jonathan M. Bell YYNY
jberger@lynx.dac.neu.edu                                     Jerry Berger YYYY
jbunin@slonet.org                                             Jerry Bunin YYYY
jcohen@DRI.cornell.edu                                Jeffrey David Cohen -N--
jdfalk@cais.com                                                 J.D. Falk YYYY
jfreed@nytimes.com                                             John Freed YYYY
jim.colwell@neopc.org                                         Jim Colwell YNNN
jimfranklin@BIX.com                      Jim Franklin jimfranklin@bix.com YYYY
joeshea@netcom.com                                               Joe Shea YYYY
John@express.demon.co.uk                                   John Honeywell YYYY
john@jlc.net                                                  John Leslie YNNN
JSCHATZ@delphi.com                                             Jon Schatz YYYY
jwilloug@gate.net                                        Jason Willoughby --Y-
jyoung@luna.cas.usf.edu                                    Jonathan Young YYYY
karromde@nyx10.cs.du.edu                                     Ken Arromdee -N--
KeithKubal@aol.com                                            Keith Kubal YYYY
kerrinp@byron.apana.org.au                                    Kerrin Pine YYYY
kieran@interport.net                                         Aaron Dickey YYYY
kim@shell.portal.com                                         Kim DeVaughn YYYN
kmccall@slonet.org                                             Ken McCall YYYY
kyum@acs.ryerson.ca                                             Kenny Yum YYYY
lantz@halcyon.com                                           Lantz Rowland YYYY
lex@nr.infi.net                                             Lex Alexander YYYY
list-votes@dream.hb.north.de                            Martin Schr\"oder YYYY
lorentz@uni-muenster.de                                       Kai Lorentz YYYY
luke@smd.smd.sublink.ORG                                 Luciano Mannucci YYYY
Lutz.Donnerhacke@Jena.Thur.De                            Lutz Donnerhacke YYYN
marc@ALGORITHMICS.COM                                      Marc Moorcroft NNNN
marcyd@math.enmu.edu                                         Darren Marcy YYYY
Marganne@aol.com                                           Marganne Meyer YYYY
matrullo@netline.net                                         Tom Matrullo NNYY
matthew@mattdl.demon.co.uk                                  Matthew Doull YYYY
meyer@newslink.org                                          Eric K. Meyer NNNN
Mikepsun@aol.com                                            Mike Phillips -NYY
MLE4312@tntech.edu                                           Margot Emery YNYY
mmt@RedBrick.COM                                            M Mike Taksar ----
modemac@netcom.com                                                Modemac YYYY
Morris@handscol.demon.co.uk                                  Morris Price YYYY
moss@bastille.cchem.berkeley.edu                                     Dave YYYY
msmccall@students.wisc.edu                               Mike McCallister YYYY
ndallen@io.org                                                Nigel Allen YYYY
nick@inferno.fc.hp.com                                     Nick Ingegneri NNNN
olaf@inka.de                                                    Olaf Titz YYY-
orc@pell.com                                                david parsons YNYY
Peter.Gugerell@inmedias.ping.at                            Peter Gugerell YYYY
pjwoos@writer.planet.net                                     Jeff Woosnam YYYY
plmad@primenet.com                                       Paul L. Madarasz YYYY
popa0200@po-box.mcgill.ca                                      Bart Beaty YYYY
ptbast@owl.WPI.EDU                                           Pete Bastien -N--
rab@hookup.net                           Aviva Rabinovici, rab@hookup.net ---Y
rballard@cnj.digex.net                                        Rex Ballard YYYY
rew@CrystalData.COM                                          Ryan Waldron NNNN
rick@bcm.tmc.edu                                           Richard Miller YNNN
rle@traveller.com                                       Robert L. Edwards NNNN
rmw463@lulu.acns.nwu.edu                                  Rebecca Winters NYNY
roberto@keltia.freenix.fr                                 Ollivier Robert YYYY
roberts@startribune.com                                    Robert Schafer YYY-
robin@DGS.dgsys.com                                       Robin Netherton YYYY
ROGERS@cas.unt.edu                                        James L. Rogers YYYY
rpl@ios.com                                              Robert A. Little ---Y
rufinus@mbe.ece.wisc.edu                                  Jeffrey Rufinus YYYY
rulrich@epix.net                                          Roger M. Ulrich YNYY
RVEITCH@atc.gov.au                                           Ross Veitch  YYYY
sam@timeout.co.uk                                              Sam Michel YYYY
sg3y+@andrew.cmu.edu                             Samuel Edward Greenfield YYYY
shecky@pipeline.com                                     Richard Scheckman YYYY
Singlis@bcde.demon.co.uk                                    Steven Inglis YNNY
smot0004@maroon.tc.umn.edu                                 Robin Smothers YNNY
stainles@bga.com                                             Dwight Brown NNNN
stevey@startribune.com                                   Steve Yelvington YYYY
stporter@iccu6.ipswichcity.qld.gov.au                        Steve Porter --YY
STYLEQUEEN@aol.com                                         Karen M. Quist YYYY
tbas@sybase.com                                              Tony Basoglu YYYY
techint@winternet.com                       Technical Intelligence-MN-USA NNYN
tgm@netcom.com                                       Thomas G. McWilliams NNNN
tgromak@kilroy.id.net                                      Tom Gromak Jr. YYYY
tomj@jac.enet.dec.com                                      Tom Jaskiewicz NNNN
topnews@ix.netcom.com                                     Howell Gatchell NNNY
tristan@dorsai.dorsai.org                                   Tristan Louis YYYY
twpierce@midway.uchicago.edu                                   Tim Pierce NNNY
uskes@mcl.ucsb.edu                                          Shannon Smith YYYY
widenius@cc.helsinki.fi                                    Risto Widenius YNNY
WNEARY@delphi.com                                            Walter Neary YYYY
x1berg@exnet.iastate.edu                                       James Berg YYYY


Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
news@telegraph-nh.com                                             David Brooks
   ! Invalid address
qpp1@iccu6.ipswichcity.qld.gov.au                                  Steve Meyer
   ! No vote statement in message
sysop@skribenten.bbs.no    Kristoffer Resellmo If you do not give a real name
   ! Invalid address

--
Steve Yelvington
Editor/Manager, Star Tribune Online, Minneapolis-St.Paul
stevey@startribune.com   SteveYelvington@ichange.com
http://www.startribune.com/online/
Voice 612-673-7229     Fax 612-673-7973

From owner-online-newspapers@marketplace.com Tue Jul 11 14:07:24 1995
Received: from marketplace.com (majordom@marketplace.com [199.45.128.10]) by cnj.digex.net (8.6.12/8.6.12) with ESMTP id OAA08174 ; for ; Tue, 11 Jul 1995 14:07:19 -0400
Received: (from majordom@localhost) by marketplace.com (8.6.12/8.6.12) id LAA20793 for online-newspapers-outgoing; Tue, 11 Jul 1995 11:23:54 -0600
Received: from interramp.com (pop3.interramp.com [38.8.32.2]) by marketplace.com (8.6.12/8.6.12) with ESMTP id LAA20787 for ; Tue, 11 Jul 1995 11:23:51 -0600
Received: from .interramp.com by interramp.com (8.6.10/SMI-4.1.3-PSI-pop-local)
	id NAA11520; Tue, 11 Jul 1995 13:19:19 -0400